Bill tries to convince a native-American businessman to partner with him in a Mormon-friendly casino. Barb warms to the idea of Ana joining the family. An annual block party becomes the battleground for Bill to defend the family, and for Nicki to defend her lifestyle.

Bill and his family test out the group-dating waters with Ana, with mixed results. Barb anxiously awaits test results from the hospital, while Nicki goes to a fertility clinic. Scott encounters unexpected resistance from Sarah when he offers to join her in Arizona.

As Bill debates what to do with Rhonda, another potential witness, Kathy, goes underground with Joey and Wanda. Frank finds himself in a bind and at Lois' mercy, and tries to talk his way out of the predicament. A revelation from Ana tests Bill's commitment.

With Roman's trial looming, Bill urges the DA to offer protective custody to Kathy and Rhonda. In an attempt to get Alby to break ranks with Roman, Bill offers an olive branch. Roman has his day in court, with his guilt or innocence hinging on Kathy and her sister.

Barb, Nicki and Margene bicker over living arrangements in the wake of the Henrickson's recent expansion. In an effort to get a bank loan for his casino venture, Bill plays hardball with brother-in-law Ted who covets a valuable historical document in Alby's possession.

The Henricksons embark on a 2,500-mile road-trip pilgrimage to a Joseph Smith shrine in New York, where Bill intends to bury a family time capsule in the sacred earth. Along the way, a series of jarring revelations test the limits of Bill's faith and their family bonds.

Nicki endures a domestic intervention by Bill and Barb, followed by an unwelcome visit by Margene. Glory smuggles a copy of a potentially incendiary church document to Bill, who isn't sure how to handle the finding. Joey looks to make a life change by adding a new wife.

Bill urges the DA's office to bring a murder charge against Roman. Bill sends Don on a road trip to investigate a tribal 'grudge' involving the casino, but learns the licence hold-up may be due in fact to his brother-in-law, Ted, and the church document he bought.

Nicki comes home after getting a call from Bill, but her spirits sag when his intentions become clear. Exposed by Cindy and Ted, Barb faces an excommunication hearing at her old church. A kidnapping involving the Greenes leads Bill to reconsider his position on Roman.

Bill convinces Ray Henry to endorse his plan to rescue a kidnapping victim while bringing down the Greenes and Roman. Nicki's web of secrets gets more tangled. Margene makes the most of her opportunity as a TV pitchwoman, and Sarah shocks the family with a revelation.