Ten new reality TV villains compete for the title of America's Ultimate Supervillain and a $200,000 cash prize; the first battle royale gives a villain immunity, and the first three villains are nominated for elimination.

The Hit List nominees compete in the season's first Redemption Challenge; New York begins having psychic visions, giving her clarity on who will win the challenge; one villain manages to annoy the rest.

Joel introduces the most villainous plot twist yet, which gives one lucky villain a secret advantage; the remaining villains dance it off in a disco themed Battle Royale, where alliances are revealed, and a new Supervillain is crowned.