Former star baseball player Kenny Powers returns to his hometown but instantly finds that he's not as respected as he once was. Training to return to the pros, Kenny becomes a full time gym teacher for the meantime.

Kenny tries to become the spokesman for a luxury car dealer. After an embarrassing scene at the car dealership, Kenny appears with his driver at a school dance and declares his love for April while high on ecstasy.

After Kenny sets Stevie up to take the rap for his own alcohol-fuelled car crash, Kenny hires Stevie as his assistant. Kenny then has Cassie sell his memorabilia on eBay and begins training and using steroids again.

Stevie puts together a DVD of Kenny's greatest moments in the hope the major leagues will take note. Later, Kenny attends a barbecue where, in front of all his friends, his boss calls him out for being a has-been.

Thanks largely to Terrence's words, Kenny decides to give up on his dream of returning to pro baseball. Meanwhile, arrogant car dealer Ashley comes back into the picture, along with the man who ended Kenny's career.

Kenny gets an offer from Tampa and says goodbye to his family and teaching job. Right before he leaves, a phone call from the agent says the deal is off and Kenny is last seen driving away with a troubled look on his face.